| # |
Year |
Name |
School |
Sport |
Team |
Position (if indicated) |
| 1 |
2009 |
Toby Peter |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Soccer |
Second-team |
MF |
| 2 |
2010 |
Toby Peter |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Soccer |
First-team |
MF |
| 3 |
2011 |
Diane Blommel |
Minnesota Morris |
Softball |
Second-team |
IF |
| 4 |
2011 |
Joelle Pipal |
Bethany Lutheran |
Women's Soccer |
Second-team |
|
| 5 |
2011 |
Brady Griffith |
Crown |
Men's Soccer |
Second-team |
|
| 6 |
2012 |
Brett Tester |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Basketball |
First-team |
|
| 7 |
2012 |
Brendon Foss |
Minnesota Morris |
Football |
First-team |
TE |
| 8 |
2012 |
Alec French |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
DB |
| 9 |
2012 |
Cory Gebhard |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
WR |
| 10 |
2012 |
Andrea Beatt |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Soccer |
Third-team |
MF |
| 11 |
2013 |
Brett Tester |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Basketball |
First-team |
|
| 12 |
2013 |
Nick Lambrecht |
St. Scholastica |
Men's At-Large (Tennis) |
Third-team |
|
| 13 |
2013 |
Krista Stoltz |
Northwestern |
Volleyball |
Third-team |
|
| 14 |
2013 |
Blake Cedarleaf |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
DL |
| 15 |
2013 |
Alec French |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
DB |
| 16 |
2013 |
Cory Gebhard |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
WR |
| 17 |
2013 |
Jake Jensen |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
RB |
| 18 |
2013 |
Casey Mitchell |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Soccer |
First-team |
MF |
| 19 |
2014 |
Nick Lambrecht |
St. Scholastica |
Men's At-Large (Tennis) |
First-team |
|
| 20 |
2014 |
Blake Cedarleaf |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
DL |
| 21 |
2014 |
Alex Mangan |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
LB |
| 22 |
2014 |
Casey Mitchell |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Soccer |
Third-team |
MF |
| 23 |
2015 |
Sally Linzmeier |
UW-Superior |
Women's Basketball |
Second-team |
|
| 24 |
2015 |
Alex Mangan |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
First-team |
LB |
| 25 |
2016 |
Ben Greener |
Northwestern |
Football |
Second-team |
LB |
| 26 |
2017 |
Karen Moe |
Northwestern |
Women's At-Large (Tennis |
Third-team |
|
| 27 |
2017 |
Jacob Gallagher |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Cross Country/Track & Field |
Third-team |
|
| 28 |
2017 |
Taylor Gibson |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Cross Country/Track & Field |
Second-team |
|
| 29 |
2017 |
Casey Hovland |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Cross Country/Track & Field |
Third-team |
|
| 30 |
2017 |
Ben Lyons |
Northwestern |
Football |
Second-team |
K |
| 31 |
2018 |
Casey Hovland |
St. Scholastica |
Women's Cross Country/Track & Field |
First-team |
|
| 32 |
2019 |
Braeden Barr |
UW-Superior |
Baseball |
Third-team |
DH |
| 33 |
2019 |
Eric Watson |
UW-Superior |
Men's Soccer |
Second-team |
F |
| 34 |
2019 |
Eva Reinertsen |
UW-Superior |
Women's Basketball |
Third-team |
|
| 35 |
2020 |
Eva Reinertsen |
UW-Superior |
Women's Basketball |
First-team |
|
| 36 |
2020 |
Connor Oldenburg |
Minnesota Morris |
Football |
Second-team |
DB |
| 37 |
2020 |
Tanner Youngberg |
Northwestern |
Men's Basketball |
Second-team |
|
| 38 |
2020 |
Ryan Steger |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Cross Country/Track & Field |
Second-team |
|
| 39 |
2020 |
Mitchell Adrian |
St. Scholastica |
Football |
Second-team |
|
| 40 |
2020 |
Max Busch |
Bethany Lutheran |
Men's Soccer |
Second-team |
F |
| 41 |
2021 |
Ryan Steger |
St. Scholastica |
Men's Cross Country/Track & Field |
First-team |
|
| 42 |
2021 |
Max Busch |
Bethany Lutheran |
Men's Soccer |
First-team |
F |
| 43 |
2021 |
Niya Wilson |
UW-Superior |
Women's Soccer |
First-team |
F |
| 44 |
2022 |
Hanna Geistfeld |
Bethany Lutheran |
Women's Basketball |
First-team |
|
| 45 |
2022 |
Eden Ambrose |
Bethany Lutheran |
Softball |
Second-team |
OF |
| 46 |
2022 |
Abby Glanzer |
Northwestern |
Volleyball |
Third-team |
|
| 47 |
2022 |
Marylyn Schroer |
Northwestern |
Volleyball |
Third-team |
|
| 48 |
2022 |
Alex Hanson |
UW-Superior |
Men's Soccer |
Third-team |
D |
| 49 |
2022 |
Niya Wilson |
UW-Superior |
Women's Soccer |
Third-ream |
F |
| 50 |
2023 |
Brenna Mattson |
UW-Superior |
Women's Soccer |
Third-team |
D |
| 51 |
2023 |
Niya Wilson |
UW-Superior |
Women's Soccer |
Second-team |
F |
| 52 |
2024 |
Jenna Anderson |
UW-Superior |
Volleyball |
Third-team |
DS/L |
| 53 |
2024 |
Sivert Klefsaas |
Northwestern |
Football |
Second-team |
RB |
| 54 |
2025 |
Eli Fest |
Bethany Lutheran |
Baseball |
Third-team |
OF |
| 55. |
2025 |
Aaron Mackall |
Minnesota Morris |
Men's Soccer |
First-team |
F |