2009
MacMurray def. Crown 68-62 (OT)
Minnesota-Morris def. Macalester 3-0
Eureka def. St. Scholastica 21-20
Westminster def. Martin Luther 28-27
Greenville def. Northwestern 26-20

2008
Macalester def. Minnesota-Morris 25-0
Martin Luther def. St. Scholastica, 77-42
Northwestern* def. Crown, 44-7
* 2008 Conference Champion

2007
Trinity Bible def. Principia, 47-20
Minnesota-Morris def. Maranatha Baptist, 48-20
Blackburn def. Crown, 42-35
Martin Luther def. Westminster, 51-36
Northwestern* def. Rockford, 28-27 (OT)
* 2007 Outright Conference Champion
North Division Won North-South Battle 4-1

2006
Blackburn def. Martin Luther 21-17
Trinity Bible def. Principia 19-13 (OT)
Maranatha Baptist def. Crown 43-12
Northwestern def. Westminster 38-19
Minnesota-Morris* def. Rockford 27-20 (OT)
* 2006 Outright Conference Champions
North Division Won North-South Battle 3-2

2005
Minnesota-Morris def. Maranatha Baptist 48-18
Principia def. Trinity Bible 43-7
Crown def. Blackburn 28-12
Martin Luther def. Rockford 26-0
Northwestern* def. Westminster 27-7
* 2005 Outright Conference Champion
North Division Won North-South Battle 4-1

2004
Principia def. Trinity Bible 46-22
Crown def. Maranatha Baptist 27-21
Minnesota-Morris def. Blackburn 34-12
Northwestern def. Rockford 28-14
Westminster 35* def. Martin Luther 35-28
* 2004 Outright Conference Champion
North Division Won North-South Battle 3-2

2003
Principia def. Trinity Bible 55-0
Crown def. Blackburn 21-12
Northwestern def. Maranatha Baptist 32-7
Rockford 34 def. Minnesota-Morris 34-27
Westminster* def. Martin Luther 28-21
* 2003 Outright Conference Champion
South Division Won North-South Battle 3-2

2002
Blackburn def. Trinity Bible 46-8
Rockford def. Macalester 25-24
Principia def. Crown 27-26
Martin Luther def. Westminster 32-28
Northwestern* def. Maranatha Baptist 9-7
* 2002 Outright Conference Champion

2001
Trinity Bible def. Crown 27-19
Mount Senario def. Maranatha Baptist 45-39
Northwestern* def. Martin Luther 32-13
* 2001 Conference Champion

2000
Crown def. Maranatha Baptist 44-28
Martin Luther def. Trinity Bible 62-6
Mount Senario* def. Northwestern 26-0
* 2000 Conference Champion