| Year |
Regular Season |
| 2024 |
Northwestern |
| 2023 |
Minnesota Morris |
| 2022 |
Northwestern |
| 2021 |
Greenville |
| 2019 |
Martin Luther |
| 2018 |
Martin Luther |
| 2017 |
Eureka |
| 2016 |
Northwestern |
| 2015 |
St. Scholastica |
| 2014 |
St. Scholastica |
| 2013 |
St. Scholastica |
| 2012 |
Greenville, St. Scholastica, Northwestern |
| 2011 |
St. Scholastica |
| 2010 |
Greenville |
| 2009 |
Martin Luther (North), Greenville (South) |
| 2008 |
Northwestern |
| 2007 |
Northwestern |
| 2006 |
Minnesota-Morris |
| 2005 |
Northwestern |
| 2004 |
Westminster |
| 2003 |
Westminster |
| 2002 |
Northwestern |
| 2001 |
Northwestern |
| 2000 |
Mount Senario |
| 1999 |
Mount Senario |
| 1998 |
Martin Luther/Maranatha/Mt. Scenario |
| 1997 |
Mount Senario |
| 1996 |
Northwestern |
| 1995 |
Martin Luther |
| 1994 |
Mount Senario |
| 1993 |
Mount Senario |
| 1992 |
Mount Senario |
| 1991 |
Concordia-St. Paul |
| 1990 |
Northwestern/Maranatha |
| 1989 |
Mount Senario |
| 1988 |
Concordia-St. Paul |
| 1987 |
Mount Senario |
| 1986 |
Northwestern (Wis.) |
| 1985 |
Mount Senario |
| 1984 |
Northwestern |
| 1983 |
Mount Scenario/Northwestern (Wis.) |
| 1982 |
Northwestern/Concordia (St. Paul)/Mt. Scenario |
| 1981 |
Northwestern/Concordia (St. Paul) |
| 1980 |
Mount Senario |
| 1979 |
Northwestern |
| 1978 |
Northwestern (Wis.) |
| 1977 |
Concordia (St. Paul)/Dr. Martin Luther |
| 1976 |
5 Teams Tied |
| 1975 |
Northwestern |
| 1974 |
Northwestern |